Become a Votebeat sponsor

Department of Justice charges 4 more noncitizens in Pennsylvania with voting in the 2024 election

The four Pennsylvania residents were among 16 people charged nationwide for voting-related crimes.

The outside of the U.S. Department of Justice Building on a sunny day with deep shadows on the stone walls from trees.
The U.S. Department of Justice Building on August 17, 2026 in Washington, DC. The department has been pursuing voting crimes around the country this fall, including in Pennsylvania. (Anna Moneymaker / Getty Images)

Votebeat is a nonprofit news organization reporting on voting access and election administration across the U.S. Sign up for Votebeat Pennsylvania’s free newsletter here.

What happened?

The Department of Justice announced Monday that four Pennsylvania residents had been charged with noncitizen voting, part of the Trump administration’s nationwide crackdown on election crimes ahead of the 2026 midterms.

In the same announcement, the department said 12 individuals in other states were also charged with noncitizen-voting-related crimes.

There is no evidence the cases are related or that voter fraud is happening on a widespread or coordinated scale.

Who was charged?

Hacina Saadi, 48; Paulo Silva, 54; Jamil Ahmad, 50; and Nighat Jamil, 47, were all charged with one count of voting by an alien during the 2024 election. Silva, Ahmad, and Jamil are all lawful permanent residents, while the Department of Justice said Saadi was residing in the country illegally.

The individuals or their attorneys did not immediately respond to emails seeking comments.

What is the context?

The charges announced Monday bring the total number of individuals charged with noncitizen-voting-related crimes in Pennsylvania to 11 since September.

Election officials contend that while voter fraud, including noncitizen voting, does occasionally happen, it is exceedingly rare.

Votebeat and Spotlight PA analyzed data on election crimes from the Pennsylvania court system, the conservative think tank the Heritage Foundation, Department of Justice press releases, and news reports dating back to mid-2015. The analysis found 165 allegedly fraudulent ballots have been cast in that time, including the four announced on Monday.

In that time period, more than 67 million votes were cast in Pennsylvania, meaning the rate of alleged fraudulent voting was roughly 0.00024%.

The Trump administration has also claimed that there are thousands of potential noncitizens on the state’s voter rolls. In July, the Department of Homeland Security claimed it had identified 250,000 potential noncitizens registered to vote in four states, including 14,576 in Pennsylvania.

Last month, Votebeat and Spotlight PA obtained an email from the DHS to Secretary of the Commonwealth Al Schmidt in which the department laid out its methodology for identifying those potential noncitizens registered to vote and offered to provide the full list to the state. However, as of today, it has not yet shared the list with Pennsylvania officials.

Carter Walker is a reporter for Votebeat in partnership with Spotlight PA. Contact Carter at cwalker@votebeat.org.

The Latest

The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact now has a realistic path to passage, but legal hurdles remain.

Now that Democrats control both the state legislature and governorship, they will have an easier time passing their priorities.

As officials in DeSoto County tally ballots for Mississippi’s history-making U.S. Senate race, voters say the use of credit bureau data to clean voter rolls meant long lines and other problems.

She spent years making sure every ballot was accounted for. On the day she died, Wisconsin Rapids held an election without her.

Democrats now have full control of the Arizona Capitol, capturing majorities in both chambers of the state legislature and the governor’s seat.

Thanks to their strong 2026, Democrats will oversee the 2028 presidential election in a plurality of states.